Can A Massage Do More Harm Than Good?

Photo of author
Written By Dr. Marcus Yu Bin Pai

MD, PhD. Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation Physician from São Paulo - Brazil. Pain Fellowship in University of São Paulo.

While most individuals correlate massages with relaxation and pain relief, it is essential to acknowledge that bodywork treatments can occasionally lead to adverse outcomes.

This article will explore the possibility of a massage inducing more harm than good, focusing on the potential risks of these therapeutic techniques. It will delve into specific situations when such touch-based therapies might be detrimental and discuss the negative side effects linked with deep tissue manipulation methods.

Furthermore, emphasis will be placed on taking precautions before therapy sessions and understanding contraindications in body manipulation treatments.

By shedding light upon these aspects, this discourse aims to foster a comprehensive awareness of massage therapy’s positive and negative implications, enabling individuals to make informed decisions regarding their health and well-being.

Objectives of a Good Massage Therapy

rolfing massage

The primary aim of a remedial massage is to alleviate physical or emotional stress, promoting relaxation and well-being. Your nervous system is pivotal in perceiving pain and soreness during and after a massage. The process starts when pressure is applied to your skin during the massage.

The pressure on your skin triggers sensors in that area, sending signals to your brain indicating a potential threat or change. Your brain receives this message and begins to evaluate the situation. It considers various factors like the stress you might be experiencing, your current emotional state, and past experiences with massage therapy before concluding if there is an actual threat or tissue damage.

If your brain interprets the signals as a threat or tissue damage, it kickstarts an inflammatory process. This process can result in the experience of pain. As a response, your muscles may tense, your heart rate and breathing may accelerate, and cortisol levels in your bloodstream may increase. These physiological changes constitute what we typically call the ‘fight-or-flight’ response.

Techniques of Deep Tissue Massage

Some common massage techniques and their technical applications, based on medical research, include:

  • Effleurage – Long, gliding strokes applied with the palms or fingertips. Can be light or deep pressure. Intended to warm-up or relax tissues, increase circulation, or guide lymph drainage. Performed along the length of the muscle.
  • Petrissage – Kneading, lifting, and squeezing tissues. Engages deeper muscles compared to effleurage. May compress tissue to enhance circulation or stretch muscle fibers to reduce spasm. Uses rhythmic movements with fingers/thumbs or whole hand.
  • Tapotement – Brisk percussive movements like tapping or cupping with the hands. Can stimulate nerve endings to activate muscles or increase local blood flow. Rhythm should be approximately 100-500 beats per minute.
  • Friction – Small circular movements over soft tissues using fingers and thumbs. Applied transversely across fibers to mobilize adhesion between tissues. Uses greater pressure but within patient’s pain threshold.
  • Vibration – Fine, oscillating movements transmitted to deeper tissues. Performed by hand or with mechanical devices. Thought to increase blood flow, relax muscles, or stimulate proprioceptors.
  • Cross-fiber friction – Force applied across the grain of soft tissues. Directed perpendicularly to disrupt adhesions between collagen fibers. Uses pincer grip of thumb and fingers intermittently.
  • Compression – Direct, steady, compressive pressure applied statically or with stroking. Intended to reduce muscle spasm, separate fascial restrictions, or reduce edema. Done with fist, forearm, or elbow.
  • Trigger point release – Ischemic compression on hyperirritable spots in muscle or fascia. Sustained pressure or strokes directed at triggering pain to relieve spasm. Patient feedback is used to guide location and pressure.

The goal, pressure, duration, and sequence of techniques should be tailored to the individual’s condition and treatment plan. Proper training is required to deliver massage safely and effectively.

Potential Risks Associated with Bodywork Treatments

While bodywork treatments such as massage can offer substantial therapeutic benefits, they also carry potential risks, including worsening of pre-existing conditions, injuries from improper technique, or adverse reactions to oils and lotions used.

Unqualified practitioners may need more expertise to correctly identify and avoid sensitive areas, potentially leading to pressure misapplication and subsequent harm. Furthermore, unsuitable techniques employed by these practitioners could inadvertently worsen underlying health issues.

Allergic reactions are another concern; some clients may experience negative responses to certain substances in the products used during treatment.

Finally, inappropriate aftercare advice or practices following a massage session might contribute to discomfort or further complications. Therefore, clients must ensure they seek services from qualified professionals and communicate their health history accurately.

Situations When Therapeutic Touch Can Be Detrimental

In certain circumstances, therapeutic touch can inadvertently exacerbate pre-existing medical conditions, leading to adverse effects rather than the intended relief and relaxation. This is particularly evident when untrained therapists administer inappropriate contact or untimely massage.

  1. Inappropriate Touch: Therapeutic touch should be applied within professional standards. Breach of these parameters may result in psychological distress.
  2.  Untimely Massage: Certain conditions, like fresh injuries or inflamed tissue, may worsen with immediate massage therapy.
  3.  Untrained Therapists: Lack of proficient training can lead to incorrect application of pressure or technique, potentially causing harm.
  4.  Inadequate Consultation & Forceful Strokes: The absence of thorough patient consultation could lead to forceful strokes on sensitive areas, aggravating existing problems instead of providing comfort and healing.

Negative Side Effects of Deep Tissue Techniques

Despite their potential healing properties, deep tissue techniques may occasionally yield adverse side effects that underscore the importance of careful application and individual suitability. These methods can inadvertently damage tissue by applying significant pressure to underlying muscles and connective tissues. Intense discomfort is a common complaint following deep tissue manipulation due to the nature of the technique.

Moreover, bruising risks are elevated due to capillaries near the surface being subject to undue pressure. Lymphatic obstruction could also occur, impeding fluid movement necessary for cellular health. Additionally, during treatment, muscular fatigue is often experienced post-massage due to intense muscle work.

Therefore, while deep tissue techniques potentially offer relief from chronic pain conditions, their application should be considered carefully in light of these possible negative outcomes.

Precautions to Take Before Therapy Sessions

Given the potential adverse effects of deep tissue techniques, certain precautions must be followed before initiating therapy sessions. Firstly, medical clearance is vital as it affirms a client’s suitability for massage therapy. It aids in avoiding complications that may arise from pre-existing conditions. Secondly, an allergy discussion should also take place between the therapist and client to prevent allergic reactions caused by oils or lotions used during therapy.

The table below further illustrates these necessary precautions:

Medical ClearanceTo avoid health issues related to pre-existing conditions.Physician’s advice is required.
Allergy DiscussionTo prevent possible allergic reactions.Therapist needs knowledge of any allergies.
Physical Limitations & Therapy IntensityTo ensure personal comfort and safety.Therapist adjusts intensity based on client’s comfort level.

These considerations are crucial in ensuring massage therapies yield positive benefits rather than harmful consequences.

Understanding Contraindications in Body Manipulation Treatments

Comprehending the contraindications associated with body manipulation treatments is vital for ensuring patient safety and optimizing treatment outcomes. A thorough Contraindications Overview can highlight potential risks, debunking common Massage Misconceptions.

  • High Risk Patients may have serious health conditions that could potentially get exacerbated by certain massage techniques.
  • Unqualified Practitioners might not be aware of these contraindications, thus putting their patients at risk.
  • Inappropriate Techniques may cause damage if applied without knowing the patient’s medical history or condition.
  • Ignorance of contraindications could result in severe repercussions.

Thus, understanding contraindications forms an integral part of any therapeutic process, including massage therapy. It is essential to educate both patients and practitioners about these factors to prevent any harm resulting from massages.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the benefits of massage therapy outweigh the potential harm for certain individuals?

The benefits of massage therapy can outweigh potential harm, yet depend on individual health conditions. Adverse reactions and medical contraindications must be considered alongside patient testimonials, massage misconceptions, and therapeutic limitations.

Are there any particular massage techniques that are generally safer than others?

Safety measures in massage therapy can reduce injury risks. Preferred techniques such as Swedish and Thai massages are generally safer, offering significant pain relief with minimal health impact compared to more intense methods.

How often should one get a massage to maximize benefits and minimize potential harm?

Massage frequency is influenced by factors such as individual sensitivity, massage duration, pre massage preparation, and post massage care. A biweekly or monthly schedule is typically recommended to balance benefits and potential harm.

What are the qualifications one should look for in a massage therapist to ensure a safe and effective treatment?

In choosing a massage therapist, considerations should include the therapist’s experience, knowledge of various massage types, certification from recognized certifying bodies, recommended treatment duration and advice on post-massage care.

Are there any long-term studies on the effects of regular massage therapy?

Long-term studies on massage therapy effects remain limited. Misconceptions, therapy resistance, and potential addiction can complicate therapeutic boundaries. Nonetheless, chronic conditions have shown improvement with regular treatment in existing research. Further investigation is necessary to substantiate these findings.


In conclusion, it is imperative to underscore the potential risks associated with bodywork treatments.

While therapeutic touch and deep tissue techniques can be beneficial for many, in certain situations these therapies might prove detrimental.

Therefore, necessary precautions must be taken prior to therapy sessions. Understanding contraindications in body manipulation treatments aids in avoiding adverse effects, illustrating that massage therapy is not universally applicable or inherently risk-free.

Website | + posts

MD, PhD. Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation Physician from São Paulo - Brazil. Pain Fellowship in University of São Paulo.

Leave a Comment